Reality television often brings relationship struggles into the spotlight, but an off-screen legal matter involving one of the latest stars of Netflix’s The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On has drawn additional attention. Blake Robertson, who appeared alongside his girlfriend Hayley Hendrich on Season 4, was arrested in Texas months after filming concluded, although the case was later dismissed.
Blake Robertson Arrested Following Filming of Netflix Series
Blake Robertson, a contestant on Season 4 of Netflix’s The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On, was arrested in October 2025 in Nacogdoches, Texas, following allegations that he assaulted his girlfriend, Hayley Hendrich.
The arrest occurred after production on the reality dating series had wrapped but before the season premiered on Netflix. The couple appeared together on the show as they navigated questions about the future of their relationship.
Attorney Says Case Was Dismissed and Records Expunged
Robertson’s attorney, Sean Hightower, said the legal matter was resolved quickly.
According to Hightower, prosecutors dismissed the case shortly after it was filed, adding that all related records were subsequently expunged.
Hayley Hendrich Declined to Pursue Charges
Hayley Hendrich confirmed that she chose not to move forward with criminal charges.
She said she and Robertson discussed the incident privately. However, she also believes accountability should extend beyond private conversations and be acknowledged publicly.
No additional details about the alleged incident have been released.
Relationship Was a Central Storyline on ‘The Ultimatum’
Season 4 of The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On was filmed during the spring of 2025 and debuted on Netflix on Wednesday.
Robertson entered the experiment after giving Hendrich an ultimatum, believing marriage was the natural next step in their relationship. Hendrich, however, expressed hesitation, saying she wanted greater emotional openness from Robertson before making a lifelong commitment.
Trial Marriages Led to Tension
As part of the show’s format, the couple temporarily separated to participate in trial marriages with other contestants.
Robertson was paired with Ashley Wilson, while Hendrich entered a trial marriage with Killian Grondin.
The experiment became increasingly tense after Hendrich learned that Grondin and some of his friends had allegedly made crude remarks about her. The revelation sparked a heated confrontation involving Hendrich, Grondin, Wilson, and Robertson, becoming one of the season’s most talked-about moments.
Couple Left the Show Together
Despite the conflicts shown throughout the season, Robertson and Hendrich ultimately left the experiment together.
However, their relationship appeared to remain uncertain, with no clear indication that they had moved significantly closer to marriage by the season’s conclusion.
Viewers are expected to learn more about the couple’s current status during the upcoming Season 4 reunion episode, where the cast will revisit the events of the season and provide updates on their relationships.
Conclusion
The legal case involving Blake Robertson was dismissed, according to his attorney, and Hayley Hendrich has confirmed that she declined to pursue charges. As audiences continue following the latest season of The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On, the reunion episode is expected to provide further insight into where the couple’s relationship stands after both the on-screen experiment and the off-screen controversy.